Homeopathic clinical case reports: Development of a supplement (HOM-CASE) to the CARE clinical case reporting guideline
R.A. van Haselenemail
International Institute for Integrated Medicine, 22 Eden Street, Suite 467, Kingston KT1 1DN, United Kingdom
Highlights
- To date, no specific guideline exists for the reporting of high quality clinical case reports in homeopathy.
- Homeopathic clinical case reporting (HOM-CASE) guideline items were identified, as an extension to the CARE clinical case reporting guideline.
- The HOM-CASE guideline extension can help to improve the quality and reliability of clinical case reports in homeopathy.
Abstract
Objective
Develop a criteria catalogue serving as a guideline for authors to improve the quality of reporting clinical case reports in homeopathy.
Method
An online Delphi process was initiated with a panel of 19 homeopathic experts from Europe, the USA and India. Homeopathy specific item selection took place in three rounds of adjusting. The selected items can be used as an extension of the CARE clinical case reporting guideline.
Results
Eight homeopathy specific ‘core’ items were selected from a list of 31 suggested items; (1) the clinical history from a homeopathic perspective; (2) the type of homeopathy; detailed description of the medication—(3) nomenclature, (4) manufacture, (5) galenic form + dosage; outcomes—(6) objective evidence if available, (7) occurrence homeopathic aggravation, (8) assessment possible causal attribution of changes to the homeopathic treatment.
A further 4 items were recommended for consideration as optional items when case reports are used for specific, in particular educational, purposes.
The 8 core items can be used, merged into 6 items, as a homeopathy specific (HOM-CASE) extension to the CARE clinical case reporting guideline items 6, 9 and 10.
Conclusion
Use of the HOM-CASE guideline extension will contribute to transparent and accurate reporting and can significantly improve the quality and reliability of clinical case reports in homeopathy.
Keywords: Homeopathy, Reporting guideline development, Clinical case reports, Modified Delphi technique
Source : http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27062953
Be the first to comment